CanopiiCanopiiAll serversEnterprise →

mcp-memory-service MCP Server Security Report

doobidoo/mcp-memory-service

Open-source persistent memory for AI agent pipelines (LangGraph, CrewAI, AutoGen) and Claude. REST API + knowledge graph + autonomous consolidation.

Security Trust Score
Grade F · Serious issues
Tier 1 · Public sourceHigh confidence · 90%latest vmain@309d938 Repository
Declared MCP capabilities
ResourcesPrompts

Run it securely

This server scored F. Run it behind runtime policy enforcement so one bad tool call can't become an incident.

Are you the maintainer?

Verify with GitHub to get alerted whenever doobidoo/mcp-memory-service changes score — and claim the badge for your README.

Claim this server
2 issues capping this score
  • criticalNo command-injection sinks — 2 occurrences
  • criticalNo dynamic code execution — 2 occurrences

The short answer

Is mcp-memory-service safe to use?
mcp-memory-service scores 14/100 (grade F) on the Canopii Trust Index, and carries 2 confirmed security failures that cap its score: No command-injection sinks and No dynamic code execution. It passes 12 of the 21 controls that apply to it.
What security issues does mcp-memory-service have?
mcp-memory-service fails 2 controls: No command-injection sinks and No dynamic code execution. Each failure on this page carries the evidence behind it — the file and line, dependency, or CVE that decided it.
How reliable is the security score for mcp-memory-service?
We could evaluate 90% of the controls that apply to mcp-memory-service. Scores are deterministic — the same source always produces the same score — and a partially-scannable server cannot present a high one, because confidence caps the result. The scanner is open source, so this score can be reproduced independently.
How was mcp-memory-service scored?
Its published source was scanned against a fixed catalog of weighted security controls covering code safety, committed secrets, dependency vulnerabilities, tool-description integrity, authentication and transport, and maintenance. A confirmed flaw caps the score outright regardless of what else passes. The full rubric is published.
Reputation2.1kstars429forks33open issuestodaylast commit2yage

Security controlslatest scored version vmain@309d938

Each control is evaluated deterministically with evidence. The score is earned from passing controls; a failed guard caps it.

Model–MCP Runtime Guardrails

  • Pass
    Indirect Prompt Injection (IPI) Defensesguardno injection markers

    Tool/prompt/resource text is free of hidden instructions that could hijack the agent.

  • Pass
    Strict JSON Schema EnforcementadditionalProperties:false present

    Tool inputs are constrained (additionalProperties:false), so unexpected arguments can't be smuggled in.

  • Pass
    Tool Definition Integrityguardtool definitions stable; no risky changes in version history

    Every consecutive version pair is diffed for new injection markers or destructive scope — a risky diff anywhere in history is a rug-pull (fail, durable); benign description drift warns.

  • Pass
    User-in-the-Loop / Approval Scopeguardno destructive tool scope

    No over-broad or destructive tools (arbitrary shell, bulk-delete) that warrant human approval.

Application Security Checks

  • Fail
    No command-injection sinksguard2 occurrences

    Untrusted tool input reaching a shell yields remote code execution. How many servers fail this?

    claude-hooks/utilities/git-analyzer.js:33claude-hooks/utilities/git-analyzer.js:59

    Fix: Never pass tool arguments to a shell; use argv arrays with shell disabled.

  • Fail
    No dynamic code executionguard2 occurrences

    eval()/exec()/Function() on tool-derived strings allows arbitrary code execution. How many servers fail this?

    claude-hooks/core/topic-change.js:159claude-hooks/utilities/dynamic-context-updater.js:381

    Fix: Remove eval/exec; parse and dispatch explicitly.

  • Warn
    No path traversalguard11 occurrences

    Naive path checks let tools read/write outside intended directories (EscapeRoute-class).

    claude-hooks/core/session-start.js:158claude-hooks/utilities/context-formatter.js:647claude-hooks/utilities/context-formatter.js:647claude-hooks/utilities/context-formatter.js:653

    Fix: Resolve to a canonical path and verify containment; reject ../ and symlinks.

  • Warn
    No SSRF sinksguard13 occurrences

    Fetching tool-supplied URLs can pivot into internal networks and metadata services.

    claude-hooks/core/memory-retrieval.js:71claude-hooks/core/session-end-harvest.js:125claude-hooks/core/session-end.js:262claude-hooks/core/topic-change.js:96

    Fix: Allow-list destinations; reject arbitrary/loopback/link-local URLs.

  • Warn
    Dependencies pinned (lockfile)no lockfile found

    A lockfile makes installs reproducible and resistant to silent dependency swaps.

    Fix: Commit a lockfile (package-lock.json / pnpm-lock.yaml / poetry.lock).

  • Pass
    No unsafe deserializationguardno sinks found

    pickle/yaml.load/etc. on untrusted data can execute code.

  • Pass
    No committed secretsguardno secrets found

    Hardcoded keys/tokens in published source are live credentials an attacker can use.

  • Pass
    Credentials sourced from environmentreads credentials from environment

    Reading secrets from env/secret stores avoids hardcoding them.

  • Pass
    Actively maintainedrecent commits

    Unmaintained servers don't receive security fixes.

  • Pass
    Repository not archivedguardactive

    Archived repositories will never be patched.

  • Pass
    Declares a licenseApache-2.0

    A clear license is required for legal enterprise use.

  • Pass
    Has a security policySECURITY.md present

    A SECURITY.md gives a private path to report vulnerabilities.

  • Pass
    Adoption & popularityestablished adoption

    A small, capped nudge from stars/downloads — widely-used servers get more eyes on bugs. It can never offset a real security failure.

  • Not checked
    No known-vulnerable dependenciesno lockfile found

    Runtime dependencies (parsed from the lockfile) are scanned against OSV.dev for published CVEs. Advisory: flagged dependencies lower the score but don't hard-cap it, since transitive reachability is unproven.

  • Not checked
    Signed releasesnot evaluated

    Signed releases let consumers verify artifacts weren't tampered with.

  • N/A
    No install/post-install scriptsguardno published package

    install hooks run arbitrary code on every consumer at install time.

  • N/A
    Package name not typosquattingguardno published package

    Names mimicking popular packages are a common malware delivery vector.

  • N/A
    Published with provenanceno published package

    Build provenance attests the artifact was built from the claimed source by CI.

  • N/A
    Established maintainerno published package

    Brand-new / single anonymous maintainers raise takeover and malware risk.

Transport & Trust Model

  • Warn
    Execution Sandboxingruns natively (no container image)

    A container/sandbox image limits blast radius; a server that runs natively has full host access.

    Fix: Ship a Dockerfile/Containerfile (or document a sandboxed run) so the server runs isolated.

  • Warn
    Network Exposurebinds 0.0.0.0

    Binding 0.0.0.0 or exposing debug inspectors widens the attack surface.

    Fix: Bind to 127.0.0.1 by default; never ship open debug endpoints.

  • N/A
    Transport Encryption (TLS)guardno remote endpoints

    Plaintext HTTP exposes traffic and bearer tokens to interception.

  • N/A
    IAM / Authentication Scopingno remote endpoints

    OAuth 2.1 / Protected Resource Metadata gates who can invoke tools.

  • N/A
    Live Endpoint Reachablenot dynamically scanned

    A dynamic scan connected to the declared remote endpoint and it responded — verified live, not a dead URL.

  • N/A
    Authentication Enforced (live)not dynamically scanned

    If the server declares auth is required, it must actually reject anonymous clients. Serving tools to unauthenticated callers is a real exposure.

Embed this score

Add the live badge to your README — it updates automatically on every rescan.

Canopii Trust Score badge preview
markdown[![Canopii Trust Score](https://index.canopii.dev/api/badge/doobidoo/mcp-memory-service)](https://index.canopii.dev/server/doobidoo/mcp-memory-service)
html<a href="https://index.canopii.dev/server/doobidoo/mcp-memory-service"><img src="https://index.canopii.dev/api/badge/doobidoo/mcp-memory-service" alt="Canopii Trust Score" /></a>

Versions

VersionScoreStatus
vmain@309d938latest14Fscored
vmain@30f9eb414Fscored
vmain@f8bbc6514Fscored
vmain@f66451b14Fscored
vmain@1f7c6df14Fscored
vmain@8823c8d14Fscored
vmain@a14f19d14Fscored
vmain@d7c845214Fscored
vmain@c37639d14Fscored
vmain@e2eb07f14Fscored
vmain@1305fee14Fscored
vmain@a2ee57d14Fscored
vmain@d3e6b5a14Fscored
vmain@1f4228e14Fscored
vmain@f67abd214Fscored
vmain@fef259d14Fscored
vmain@ba3105514Fscored
vmain@9cab16d14Fscored
vmain@ef25b9314Fscored
vmain@c1c312114Fscored
vmain@441e0ee14Fscored
vmain@168337a14Fscored
vmain@2601f0814Fscored
vmain@09334cc14Fscored
vmain@a7c1f0314Fscored
vmain@bff43dc14Fscored
vmain@e36954114Fscored
vmain@f6bec0a14Fscored
vmain@1a5da6714Fscored
vmain@4f784cc14Fscored
vmain@2a182d014Fscored
vmain@563737514Fscored
vmain@80ee4db14Fscored
vmain@5c9f37714Fscored
vmain@f67fe1e14Fscored
vmain@4849dba14Fscored
vmain@139e43f14Fscored
vmain@f47802914Fscored
vmain@7c8b2dd14Fscored
vmain@59ba65114Fscored
vmain@cec0cbe14Fscored
vmain@a95f85f14Fscored
vmain@d40e6d614Fscored
vmain@0f6955414Fscored
vmain@05f896114Fscored
vmain@4a2253414Fscored
vmain@0ced0d514Fscored
vmain@975a23614Fscored
vmain@60f5fab14Fscored
vmain@598517814Fscored
vmain@46793ef14Fscored
vmain@236ef1814Fscored
vmain@cd1f18114Fscored
vmain@e8960eb14Fscored
vmain@24f354314Fscored
vmain@22c3dde14Fscored
vmain@244c00c14Fscored
vmain@dfa3e4614Fscored
vmain@f2c58c014Fscored
vmain@3a360b514Fscored
vmain@46e20af14Fscored
vmain@797900a14Fscored
vmain@e5155b914Fscored
vmain@a605edc14Fscored
vmain@f3c20d014Fscored
vmain@a25459c14Fscored
vmain@1ed92cd14Fscored
vmain@a54aa8b14Fscored
vmain@bf23aec14Fscored

Wondering how this compares? The MCP Security Index tracks grade distribution, committed secrets, and missing authentication across the whole ecosystem, refreshed monthly.